| Surviving
in Symbols: A Visit to the Pictish Nation. Martin Carver £5.99
The Making of Scotland Series, Historic Scotland/Canongate, Edinburgh,
1999. ISBN 086241 873 3
In this slim, lavishly illustrated volume, Carver
summarises much of what we know about the Picts from contemporary
written sources and from what can be surmised from the archaeological
evidence currently available. The text is laudably free from romantic
speculation; indeed a judicious degree of caution is evident throughout.
Rather than tackle the thorny question of the limits of Pictish
territory, Carver contents himself with the plain notice “the
eastern part of Scotland, called here Pictland..” before going
on to describe the nature of the available evidence on Pictish culture.
In short, concise sections on topics such as the meaning of the
symbols or on where the Picts came from, he makes plain that there
has been or is still a deal of scholarly debate in many areas of
Pictish studies.
The artist’s sketches illustrating aspects
of Pictish life worked less well for this reader than the many maps,
plans of sites and photographs of sites, stones and artefacts which
are well chosen to bring to life the nature of the evidence which
Carver presents.
The presentation and clarity of style combine to
make this a very useful introduction to the current state of knowledge
about the Picts, and one that can easily be enjoyed by any non-specialist.
Sheila Hainey
|