Viking Scotland by Anna Ritchie (B
T Batsford, 1993). PB; 143 ps. £14.99
This and a work on Edinburnh Castle by Iain MacIvor are the first
to be issued of a series of Batsford publications under the title
Historic Scotland, which will be the Scottish equivalent of the
successful series of books about English archaeology entitled English
Heritage.
This is a handsomely produced volume, copiously
illustrated to a high standard on almost every page with black and
white and colour photographs, maps, site plans and line drawings.
The cover photograph of part of the Jarlshof site is full of the
brilliant light and sense of space of the Northern Isles (when the
weather's decent), and evokes the marvellous scenery in which many
of our Viking sites are to be found.
It is always a pleasure to have another book by
Dr Ritchie in one's library, and Viking Scotland comes up to her
expected standard of a popular and eminently readable text which
is also scholarly and informative.
The book covers the main periods of Viking, Scandinavian
or Norse history (the differing meanings of these terms, too often
used interchangeably, are brought out in the first chapter), and
the main archaeological sites and finds, both upstanding and excavated.
Scotland has a splendid heritage of these (and potentially many
more to be discovered): "Less than twenty Norse settlements
have been identified and excavated, but this is a rich haul compared
to other areas of the Norse colonies . ." (9). One ofthe most
useful things about this book is that it summarises and interprets
the knowledge gained from the excavated Norse settlement sites,
burials, hoards and so on from all over the country. It is very
worthwhile having this information gathered together in a single
volume, not least because so many of even the most important sites
are still unpublished (a problem all too familiar - and even more
serious - in Pictish archaeology).
Due weight is given to the interaction between
the Viking raiders or settlers and the "Natives" they
encountered, the Picts and Scots. The second chapter "Scotland
before the Vikings" is in fact a good summary of current knowledge,
and perhaps no author before has brought out the probable influence
ofthe Celtic population on the Norse settlers so strongly: it is
fascinating to read, for instance, that analysis ofthe folklore
of the Northern Isles shows that it has pre-Norse roots (28), or
that Pictish house-types may have influenced those of the Norse
settlers (49). Has anyone ever looked for Pictish words in the Norn
dialect of Shetland?
The third chapter "Viking Age Scotland AD
780-1100" is a good general introduction to the archaeological
evidence for daily life, burials and artefacts. Despite a certain
amount of documentary evidence for Norse history, little of it contemporary
except the Irish annals, the main source of knowledge about the
Vikings is archaeology, supplemented by place-names. This chapter
sets the scene for the following three, which look more closely
at what has been found, or can still be seen in the field, site
by site, in the Northern Isles and Caithness "the Viking heartland",
Argyll and the Western Isles and southern and eastern Scotland.
Orkney has been and continues to be the richest
area for Viking and later Norse remains. Important finds are made
quite frequently, often revealed by coastal erosion, such as the
richly furnished boat-grave found in 1991 at Scar on Sanday. A full
page is rightly given over to a photograph of the superb C9th whalebone
plaque found here, one of the finest Norse artefacts ever found
in the British Isles (45), and it appears again in colour on the
back cover. Norse Orkney also comes into focus by being the main
background to Orkneyinga Saga which, though not a strictly historical
work, casts light on what was happening at a large number of individual
sites. One such is Westness on Rousay, Vestrnes in the Saga, the
site of important Norse (and Pictish) discoveries, which may be
the most complete Viking landscape known in Scotland (52).
Shetland is much less well known, not least because
the author of Orknevinga Sang who, it is suggested, may have been
an Icelander based at Thurso (15), was not very interested in it.
Mainland Shetland does, however, contain the supremely important
site of Jarlshof. It is suggested that the earliest intensive Norse
settlement was in the more fertile lands of Orkney, and that Shetland
was only settled when the better land further south had been taken,
which may explain the continuing tradition of Picto-Scottish stone
sculpture in Shetland, for which there is no evidence in Orkney
(28).
In Argyll and the Western Isles the archaeological
picture is dominated by Viking burials and their often rich grave-goods,
which are described in detail here. A small lapdog was found with
a female burial at Machrins on Colonsay, and the idea has been put
forward that it could have been used not only as a pet but as a
living hot-water bottle (85-6). Similar wee doggies seem to appear
on some Pictish carvings. Only two settlements in the Hebrides have
been excavated, at Drimore on South Uist and at the Udal on North
Uist, the latter a site which, if it ever gets published, should
have the same impact on all periods of the archaeology of the Western
Isles as Jarlshof did on Shetland.
The "Viking fringe" of southern and eastern
Scotland, described in the sixth chapter, was less intensely affected
by the Norse, although raiding is recorded in the historical sources;
the hoards that have occasionally been found in the south could
relate to this. This part of Scotland may, however, have been rather
more influenced by the Danes settled in northern England; any settlers
probably spread north from there, bringing with them the fashion
for hogback monuments.
The following chapter on late Norse Scotland deals
with a time when the Norse settled in the north and west had ceased
to be "Viking" barbarians, and were rather full participants
in the civilisation of north-west Europe. The achievements of the
Earldom of Orkney, with its far-flung cultural connections, which
culminated in the construction of St Magnus' Cathedral in Kirkwall,
stand out in this context. On a smaller scale from the churches
and castles of the Earls, the Lewis chessmen, perhaps originally
a trader's hoard, provide: "The most popular image of Scandinavian
Scotland" (106). It is interesting to read that late Norse
churches survive in the Western as well as the Northern Isles (110-1),
and this is a reminder of just how strong and long-lasting Norse
power was over the fringes of Scotland. Runes are also given an
airing in this chapter. Isn't it about time someone did a corpus
of these? Many of the (quite impressive) number of Scottish examples
are very inadequately published.
The final chapter describes the continuing importance,
and modern celebrations of, the Norse inheritance. This is followed
by a list of monuments and museums to visit, a short reading list,
glossary and index.
The book contains several line reconstruction drawings
of ancient scenes, clothing etc. An aerial drawing of the first
attack on lona (20) gives a good impression of the layout of the
C8th monastery, as far as it is known, with a raven (one of Odin's
messengers?) hovering ominously above. A reconstruction of Cubbie
Roo's Castle on Wyre (123) shows a tall keep with the surviving
chapel nearby, and a large drinking-hall at the Bu beyond - an example
of how a convincing representation of the past can be built up from
a number of sources.
It seems almost churlish to point out two tiny
errors in a work of this quality, but that is part of the reviewer's
job: the Gaelic spelling of the site of A Cheardach Mhor ("The
Big Smithy") on South Uist (21-2) is not quite correct (it
should be A' Cheardach Mhor), and on page 107 it would perhaps be
best (with readers new to the subject in mind) to point out that
"the earldom" in question is that of Orkney. Dr Ritchie
has produced a splendid popular introduction to Viking Scotland,
which it will be a pleasure to read for years to come, and which
perfectly complements B E Crawford's more specialised Scandinavian
Scotland (Leicester U P, 1987). I look forward to her second Batsford
book on Prehistoric Orkney
Other books of interest due to be published in
the Historic Scotland series will include: Picts and Scots by Sally
Foster; Iron Age Scotland by Ian Armit; Stone Age Hunters of Scotland
by Caroline Wickham-Jones; Temples and Tombs by Patrick Ashmore;
Scottish Abbeys and Priories by Richard Fawcett; Roman Scotland
by David Breeze and Medieval Scotland by Peter Yeoman.
Niall M Robertson
|