The ancient monuments of Shetland
by Noel Fojut and Denys Pringle, edited by Chris Tabraham (HMSO,
1993) PB; 64 ps £3.95
Times have changed since the old days of the uniform blue Ancient
Monument guidebook with dry text and four or five black and white
photos; this popular introduction to The ancient monuments of Shetland,
with its use of modern graphics and colour illustrations on nearly
every page, is clearly designed to appeal to the modern tourist
market. There is nothing wrong with that, of course, and many will
find this kind of user-friendly but informative publication an asset
in the field or on their bookshelf.
Shetland's Ancient Monuments are justly famous,
but it is good to see sites not in the care of Historic Scotland
covered here too; with discussion of the historical and environmental
background to the visible remains, this book is an effective summary
of the impact of human beings on these islands over some six millennia.
The photographs, many of which show the monuments
in the spectacular landscapes so characteristic of Shetland, are
generally of high quality. I am less happy with a number of plans,
reconstructions, etc, drawn in coloured pencil, but one showing
the original appearance of the Staneydale "Temple" gives
a good impression of what must have been an awe-inspiring building.
The accompanying discussion of what its function might have been
is intriguing, though inevitably inconclusive. The fact that the
"Temple" is a component of one of the well-preserved Prehistoric
landscapes that stretch for miles on end over large parts of the
islands is brought out, and this is probably the most remarkable
feature of Shetland for the archaeologist. The "Temple"
is perhaps the finest monument of the Neolithic or Bronze Ages to
survive in Shetland - in interesting contrast to Orkney with its
many chambered caims and megaliths - but Shetland comes into its
own with spectacular Iron Age fortifications such as the Brochs
of Mousa and Clickhimin.
The interface between Iron Age times and the at
least protohistoric Pictish centuries is as yet a mysterious one
in Shetland, as elsewhere; the text states: ", for the period
around the end of the Iron Age and the start of the Dark Ages, about
AD 500, it is hard to identify any houses, and only one burial [a
square cairn found at Sandwick, Unst in 1978 - Ed] is known"
(30). Pictish Shetland is dealt with in only two pages, and no monuments
from these centuries - apart from some minor structures at Jarlshof
- are in guardianship. The St Ninian's isle hoard is, of course,
mentioned and some of its pieces illustrated. There are important
Early Christian carved stones from Shetland. not shown here, and
the authors put forward the surely rather controversial suggestion
that the church sites they were found at: ", suggest a parish
structure established in the heart of the best farmland, and apparently
serving the local people" (3 1-2). And this before the arrival
of the Vikings
The Scandinavian takeover of the islands, from
what may have been a ", demoralised or numerically much-reduced"
(33) Pictish population, is undocumented, but seems to have been
swift and comprehensive. Considering the pride that Shetlanders
take in their Norse heritage, the fame of the settlement at Jarlshof
should not blind one to the fact that surprisingly few Viking structures
have been excavated on Shetland, and even fewer are still visible.
Shetland was part of the Earldom of Orkney, and the Scandinavian
impact on the islands is well covered here.
By the later Middle Ages, the Northern Isles were
increasingly within the orbit of mainland Scotland, and came to
be ruled by a notoriously tyrannical offshoot of the Scottish royal
house These Robber-Earls and their henchmen had a discriminating
taste in architecture, however, and the castles of Scalloway and
Muness - the latter the most northerly in the British isles - survive
as witness.
The final part of the book bring Shetland's story
up to modem times, with chapters on the rise of Lerwick and on Fort
Charlotte - a fine example of an C18th artillery fortification,
now rather swamped by the buildings of the modem town, which has
never yet seen a shot fired in anger.
Those visiting Shetland will find this book a helpful
one to take along, and its combination of attractive presentation
with interesting text make it a concise and valuable introduction
to these islands - a format it might be hoped will be followed for
other areas too.
Niall M Robertson
|